Preface

I first visited Israel in 1967.

A few weeks after my arrival, war began and Israel occupied vast territories.

After some time, I saw some white rubble scattered on the field around a kibbutz. It was only after seeing an old map, which had been printed before the creation of the state of Israel, that I understood that these were ruins of Palestinian villages.

This was how I came to know about the issue of Palestine.

 

People have disappeared from the villages, the names of the villages have disappeared from maps, and people who remember about the old times pass away one after another. On top of it, the world has kept hiding all this.

 

Nowadays, only extremely few people who remember about 1948, when people became refugees and the villages were destroyed, remain.

 

60 years from this Palestinian catastrophe called Nakba, the number of people who suffer keeps increasing.

I wanted to make records of the vanished villages and people, and also to remember them, so I have started to work on this vast archive with the help of many people.

"Ryuichi Hirokawa Archives - Palestine 1948 NAKBA" consists of nine chapters with thirty DVDs, as we will show you in the "contents" section later.

I have devoted many chapters of this work to issues that the Jewish people and Israel are currently facing, so that the audience can understand the depth of this problem.

In the English version, we have inserted timing codes in each chapter for researchers to reference in articles or reports.

I have tried to make the last chapter, Chapter 9, into a structure which I hope second and third generation refugees might find helpful to investigate about their ancestral villages.

 

I hope this work will be useful to help people understand the issue of Palestine. Even more, I hope that it will contribute even slightly to resolution of the issue.

 

October 2008

Ryuichi Hirokawa

 

 

Endorsements to Ryuichi Hirokawa Archives Palestine 1948 NAKBA

 

The massive film archives, which Ryuichi Hirokawa has accumulated during the course of his forty-year engagement with the Palestine Question, have immeasurable value as oral history documents as well as a compilation of oral-visual histories offered in a package fitting to a new era. No intellectual attempts, be it a study on Palestine -Jewish questions, the Middle East and Islamic world, International Relations or War and Peace, can ignore this important work. The archives are equipped with a search and adduction function to accommodate the needs of academic researchers. This will likely facilitate widespread use in the international community. Given this potential of opening up a new public sphere, the arrival of the archives edition surely is a groundbreaking event for the Japanese society that has been seriously committed to the Palestine Question.

Yuzo Itagaki, Professor Emeritus of the University of Tokyo

 

The archives edition is extremely valuable for researchers in Israel-Palestine issues as it contains many testimonies and visual images made available for the first time in the world. I believe the archives will not only help rethinking of the NAKBA and wider sharing of its memories but also mark the beginning of a new quest for solutions to still-lingering problems and those issues not well-known to the Japanese society, such as the question of the state and identity.

Akira Usuki, Professor of Japan Women's University

 

 

Contents of Ryuichi Hirokawa Archives

Palestine 1948 NAKBA

DISC1


DISC2

 

 

 

 

 

 

DISC3

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

DISC4

 

THE BEGINNING                         

                

CHAPTER 1  What Happened in 1948

1-1  The Two Daliyas

-- Residents of Kibbutz Dalia

-- Villagers from Daliyat al-Rawha

1-2  From the Jewish Viewpoint

The Myth of Independence Borne Out of Calamity   Elal Pered—Jew, Former Commander of Palmach

Tragedies of Jews  Ora Rutenberg – Jewish resident of Kibbutz Kfar Etzyon  

1-3  In Search of Truth in History

Haganah and Palmach   Pinhas Ophel -- Jew, Former Palmach Trooper

Trends of Jewish Political Groups  Akiva Orr -- Jew, Former Matzpen Member

Activities of the Jewish Right Wing  Itzhak Hason -- Jew, Former Right Winger

Memories of Battle  Amnon Neuman – Jew, Former Palmach Trooper

How to Face History   Akiva Orr – Jew, Former Matzpen member

Excavation and Justification of History  Benny Morris -- Jew, Professor of History

The Truth of 1948  Ilan Pappe – Jew, Professor of History

 

CHAPTER 2  Massacres in Villages and Towns

2-1  Dayr Yasin Village  Meir Pail --Jew, Former Palmach Commander  

Yehuda Lapidot – Jew, Former Irgun (right-wing militia) commander

Sharif Kanafani – Jew, Anthropologist

Munif Jaber / Ibrahim Hamid / Mustafa Hamideh / Fahmi Jaber / Watfah Zaidan

 -- Villagers from Dayr Yasin

2-2  Tantura Village

Muhammed Tanzi – Palestinian, Director of the Tantura Historical Archives

Fawzi Tanzi / Ali Mustafa -- Villager from Tantura  Theodor Katz -- Jewish Historian

Yoel Solnik -- Veteran of the Alexandroni Brigade

2-3  Dawayima Village

Sharif Kanafani -- Palestinian Anthropologist

Ibrahim Najufa -- Second-generation Refugee from Dawayima, History Researcher

Haim Abradam – Jewish resident of Amatzia

Haddad Mustafa / Rahbiya Sabateen / Salim Sabateen / Khalid Abu Tamaha --Villagers from Dawayima

DISC5

2-4  Lydda Town

Arnaki Ahmed -- Palestinian in Lydda,  Pinhas Ophel – Jew, Former Palmach Trooper

 

 

DISC6

 

 

 

 

DISC7

 

 

 

 

CHAPTER 3   Palestinians in Israel

3-1  Iqrit and Kafr Bir'im Villages

Mohammed Bakri -- Palestinian Film Actor/Director    Bassem Jacob -- Second-generation Refugee from Iqrit

Jacob Ayat -- Second-generation Refugee from Iqrit  Tomah Maghzar -- Refugee from Kafr Bir`im
3–2  The Two Villages of ‘Ayn Hawd

Assem Abu-Heija -- Palestinian Resident of New ‘Ayn Hawd  Dan Benarie -- Jewish Resident of Old ‘Ayn Hawd

3-3  Seeking Equality

Resistance or Coexistence? Mohammed Bakri – Palestinian Film Actor/Director

The Hebron Massacre  Fakhri Juday – Palestinian Pharmacist in Israel
Failed Attempt at Coexistence
 Nel Radlas -- Seeds of Peace Center for Coexistence

A Father Who Lost His Son  Hassan Asri, Palestinian resident of Sakhnin

 

 

DISC8

 

 

DISC9

 

 

DISC10

CHAPTER 4   Palestinian Refugees in Lebanon

4-1  The Massacre of 1982

4-1-1 The Massacre of Sabra and Shatila - The Testifiers [1]

Ellen Siegel -- A nurse, Jewish American,  Shahila Rudaine / Milane Borje -- Witnesses of massacre

4-1-2  The Massacre of Sabra and Shatila - The Testifiers [2]

Amne Banad (Missing People from the Massacre),

Dareen and Sabreen / Nadim Nasser (The Story of a Twin Sister) Beit Atfal al-Somud (Children's Home)

4-1-3  The Massacre of Sabra and Shatila - The Testifiers [3]

Iftikar Shleiff / Fatima Touza / Amne Hamdan / Abdel-Nasser Alameh / Sanaa Salsawi / Samih Haziza / Abir Brir

DISC11

 

 

 

DISC12

 

 

 




DISC13

 

4-2   Kifah’s Story

Mervat Afifi / Kifah Afifi / Leah Tzemel / Yasmin Hasaneen

 

CHAPTER 5  Occupation, Peace and War 1967 – 2007

5-1

1967-1993                         

5-2

Peace of Rabin

5-3

Welcoming Peace

5-4

Opposition Against Peace

5-5

Settlers

5-6

Rabin’s Death

5-7

Intifada

5-8

Suicide Bomb

 

5-9

Southern Lebanon under Occupation

5-10

Jerusalem

5-11

Gaza

5-12

Jenin

5-13

Under Military Blockade

5-14

Checkpoint and the Wall

DISC14

 

 

 

DISC15

 

DISC16

 

 

DISC17

DISC18

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

CHAPTER 6  Jewish Peace Activists

6-1  Working with Palestinian People [1]

Peace Now, Gush-Shalom, Uri Avnery - Former Knesset Member, Women in Black,

Ta'ayush, Yeshayahu Leibovitz - Professor at Hebrew University, Yesh G'vul, Zochrot

6-1  Working With Palestinian People [2]

Daria Lando - Jewish kindergarten manager, Pnina Feiler – Jew, "Physicians for Human Rights"

6-2  Matzpen [1]

Giyora Noyman / Ehud and Aviva Engil / Marius Shatnell / Michael Balshevski /

Matzpen Symposium (Eran Tubinel / Leah Tzemel / Ahmad Massalwi / Haim Hanegbi / Akiva Orr)

6-2   Matzpen [2]       Akiva Orr,  Oded Pilavsky

6-3  Interviews with Shlomo Sand [1] October 1993 - July 2000

No.1  October 1993 -- What the Peace Agreement Will Bring About

No.2  October 1993 -- Withdrawal of Settlements and Russian Immigrants

No.3  March 1994 -- Conversation With a Taxi Driver

No.4  March 1994 – One Crime Justifying Another Crime

No.5  November 1995 -- Assassination of the Prime Minister, and the "Promised Land"

No.6  November 1995 -- Will Israel Change?

No.7  April 1997 -- What People Can Create Out of Despair

No.8  July 2000 – The Nation State and Democracy

DISC19

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

DISC20

 

 

 

 

 

DISC21

 

6-3  Interviews with Shlomo Sand  [2] (September 2000 – November 2006

No.9   September 2000 -- Oriental Jews          No.10  October 2000 -- The Second Intifada

No.11  November 2000 -- Democratizing Israel    No.12  March 2001 --“More Land, Fewer Goats”

No.13  July 2001 --“Ugliness of the Strong”        No.14  September 2001--“State of Apartheid”

No.15  October 2001 --“Assassination of a Minister”    No.16   January 2002 -- Suicide Bomb Attacks

No.17  February 2002 --“Intensified Clashes”     No.18   July 2003 -- People Against the Peace Process

No.19  July 2003 --“Return of the Refugees”     No.20  January 2005 -- Israel's "Civil War"

No.21   November 2006 -- Who Are the Jews? 

 

CHAPTER 7 Jewish Identity

7-1            Biblical Archeology    Shlomo Sand, Professor of History, Tel Aviv University 

Ze'ev Herzog, Professor of Archaeology, Tel Aviv University

Adam Zartal, Professor of Archaeology, Haifa University
Israel Finkelstein-- Head of the Department of Archaeology, Tel Aviv University

7-2    Biblical Studies  Nadav Na'aman, Professor of Tel Aviv University

7-3    Genetics   Batsheva Bonne-Tamir , Professor of Human Genetics, Tel Aviv University

7-4    Resolution of the Jewish Conversion Law  Tedi Tzuker, Member of Meretz Party

7-5    Jewish Religion and Jewish People  Akiva Orr, Former Matzpen Member

 

 

 

 

 

7-6    "Neturei Karta"  Josua Scoult, A Religious Jew against Zionism

7-7    Nation and Religion  Shlomo Sand, Professor of History, Tel Aviv University

7-8    Oriental Jew  Shlomo Sand, Professor of History, Tel Aviv University

7-9    Jewish people of the Khazar Empire Yehud Yaari, TV Newscaster
7-10   Jewish Origin  Shlomo Sand, Professor of History, Tel Aviv University

 

 

Disc22

CHAPTER 8  Returning to the Villages

8-1     Zakariyya Village   Ziad Shamluk, Palestinian , Co-chair of the Ibdaa Cultural Center

8-2     Tall al-Safi Village  Ramadan Abu-Bahadel, A Boy from the Shaati Refugee Camp

Muhammad, Uncle of Ramadan,  Azmi Ra'az, Son of Ex-chief of Tall al-Safi village

8-3     Barqusya Village    Omar Kashaan, Second-generation Refugee from Barqusya

8-4     Mi'ar Village      Ali Taha, Palestinian writer and refugee from Mi’ar

Lifta Village     Mohammed Musa, Refugee from Lifta

 

 

CHAPTER 9  Palestinian Villages Demolished (286 total)

Disc23

9-1     The District of Acre (Akka)  - 16 Villages

Disc24

9-2     The District of Acre (Akka)  - 8 Villages   The District of Beisan - 9 Villages, 
The District of Gaza - 39 Villages

Disc25

9-3    The District of Haifa  - 38 Villages

Disc26

9-4     The District of Haifa  - 5 Villages            The District of Hebron - 15 Villages

The District of Jaffa - 17 Villages

Disc27

9-5     The District of Jerusalem - 27 Villages

Disc28

9-6     The District of Jenin - 4 Villages               The District of Nazareth - 5 Villages   

The District of Al-Ramla - 39 Villages

Disc29

9-7     The District of Safad - 41 Villages

Disc30

9-8     The District of Tiberias - 15 Villages           The District of Tulkarem - 8 Villages